Moral Queasiness & The ICJ Ruling

 
Source: Middle East Eye “U.S. doubles down on dismissing genocide claim despite ICJ ruling

If you look up “moral queasiness” in the dictionary you’ll likely see a picture of some U.S. government official or other spinning support for Israel’s genocide in Gaza. Above, we see how Security Council spokesperson John Kirby looked when journalists asked at a White House press briefing on January 26 about whether the ICJ ruling would affect U.S. policy. 

Short answer: not at all.

Reactions to the ICJ ruling have ranged from squirming while delivering weasel words to thundering jeremiads, such as this one from Shahid Bolsen of Middle Nation which includes his bottom line: “Anything that discredits western colonial institutions is a good thing.”

My friend Janet Kobren put together this nifty side by side comparison chart to help us sort through the provisions the ICJ ordered versus those South Africa asked them to order.

I’ve previously shared former UK ambassador Craig Murray’s reporting from the courtroom which was valuable as he was THE ONLY press person in the room. Now comes his analysis, “Has International Law Survived, or Has the Western Political Class Killed Itself?”

That the ICJ has not affirmed Israel’s right to self-defence is perhaps the most important point in this interim order. It is the dog that did not bark. The argument which every western leader has been using is spurned by the ICJ. [emphasis mine]

No wonder the White House spox is squirming.

Moderates found the ICJ ruling encouraging despite the fact that its opening paragraph condemned Hamas but nowhere in the document was there mention of the thousands of Palestinians held in Israel’s prisons. You know, the prisoners that Hamas wants to swap for the hostages taken on October 7.

In case U.S. taxpayers weren’t thoroughly nauseated yet, the UN Relief and Works Agency for Palestine (UNRWA) was defunded by the western axis of evil for supporting Hamas. 

As Palestinians in Gaza are literally starving to death! Many see the timing as a ploy to distract from the ICJ ruling.

Not to worry, though. Court cases against Israel and also the U.S. for supporting Israel’s genocide abound. Here’s news of a promising suit filed in on behalf of surviving family members heard in federal court in California last week:

If 11,000 Gazan children slaughtered in four months while Biden and Congress cheer from the sidelines doesn’t induce moral queasiness, there’s probably not much hope for humanity. Will Israel and the U.S. refrain from unleashing the horror of nuclear weapons? Do government officials of those nations have a shred of conscience left to inform this existential decision?

College Students Taking The Lead Standing Up For Gaza


I often experience a push-pull between organizing and writing; both are time intensive and, for me, best done earlier in the day. Yesterday was a case in point. I had two unwritten blog posts cued up, one about the moral queasiness of U.S. government responses to the International Court of Justice (ICJ) ruling against Israel’s genocide in Gaza and one about the pernicious lie that eternal wars are a good jobs program.

But then the efforts of many organizers in a statewide coalition here in Maine paid off and my husband and I spent the day in Farmington near the U Maine campus at a rousing protest for Gaza.

All four corners of a downtown intersection were filled as more than 50 people showed up. Several of the students said some version of, This never happens in Farmington. About half of those who came were students, the result of fantastic organizing by the new Students for Justice in Palestine (SJP) chapter on campus. They did this despite their fears of losing financial aid for speaking up against genocide — yes, we are in that world.

In contrast to other Saturday afternoon protests around Maine, no passing cars honked. One rolled down the window to yell, You are supporting people who rape their own babies — showing that propaganda works, especially on people who want to hate and don’t want to examine actual evidence. Farmington is less of a college town and more of an economically struggling former mill town. Left-leaning students say they feel isolated on campus and that most students are apathetic.

Well, they weren’t isolated yesterday and many reported that made them feel hopeful. 

Students who spoke after we reconvened in a nearby park gazebo shared that they will be pressing UMF and other U Maine campuses to divest from apartheid Israel. This is the D in BDS, a highly effective way to bring pressure and the reason that many U.S. states have outlawed it at the bidding of the Israel lobby.

Other notes: a student who’ll be interviewed soon on radio about this work got some support and coaching from a young teacher who often acts as an articulate spokesperson for the Maine Coalition for Palestine. Yay!

Two students from the far away University of Southern Maine had driven up from Biddeford to attend the protest after they heard about it through SJP on their campus and also Healthcare Workers for Palestine.

Would it surprise you to know that even though a press release with powerful quotes from students went out to all media in Maine, not a single reporter showed up?

We didn’t attempt our usual group picture but I did try to take a panoramic shot when most of us were in the gazebo for cookies, tabling, and speeches.

When it was my turn, I spoke about the ICJ case — subject of my recorded interview the previous day in response to a blog post “If Gaza Were In Maine..” That post shared an powerful map analogy that I expanded on but did not create.

Map created by Will T of the Maine Coalition for Palestine

So the synergy between writing and organizing is a thing. Even though one makes me feel like my head is going to explode while the other reduces the pressure (I’ll let you guess which is which), they’re both things I can do on behalf of those living under siege and watching their children die of dehydration.

I still want to write that post on the ICJ decision once I’ve had time to consider the varied responses I’ve seen and heard so far.

But first, there’s some organizing that needs my immediate attention.